The Ledger

Isaac Bonewits’s twenty-six laws of magic, checked against the ordinary world.

Evidence tier: Interpretive. This supplement inherits the tier of its parent essay. The verdicts are readings of the evidence discussed there, not tests. Evidence Protocol

Of the twenty-six laws in Isaac Bonewits’s Authentic Thaumaturgy, 1 holds as written, 15 hold in a narrower form, 5 are not kept, and 5 cannot be tested as stated. That is fewer than he hoped, more than we notice, and almost never in the form he stated.

The ledger applies the essay’s three rules. A resemblance between two wonders is not a shared cause. An invented scene says that it is invented. An effect is stated at the size the evidence gives it. Law names and order follow Wikipedia’s summary of Authentic Thaumaturgy. The statements are paraphrased, not quoted. Section numbers refer to the essay.

Kept as written: the law holds as Bonewits states it. Kept narrowly: a smaller version holds, and the ledger says which. Not kept: the evidence in the essay does not support it. Not testable: nothing could count for or against it as stated.


The ledger

LawWhat it claimsWhat the ordinary world keepsVerdict
1. KnowledgeUnderstanding a subject gives control over it.Understanding helps where a system is stable and the person can act on it: a vaccine, a bridge. It is necessary more often than it is sufficient. Weber’s streetcar rider understands nothing and still gets to work (Section II).Kept narrowly
2. Self-KnowledgeThe most important magical knowledge is knowledge of oneself.Knowing your limits helps, but people report poorly on their own mental processes (Nisbett and Wilson 1977). Self-knowledge works as a discipline backed by feedback, not as a starting condition.Kept narrowly
3. Cause and EffectThe same actions under the same conditions give the same results.This is the premise of experiment. Conditions never repeat exactly, so the working form is statistical: similar actions in similar conditions give similar distributions of results. The Mozart and learning-styles claims failed that test (Section II).Kept narrowly
4. SynchronicityEvents that happen together share more than their timing.Nothing beyond chance, selection, and memory. The count in Section IV (Littlewood; Samuels and McCabe; Diaconis and Mosteller) removes the need for the law.Not kept
5. AssociationPatterns that share elements interact through them.True and close to trivial: things that share a component can affect each other through it. As a law it predicts nothing until someone names the component.Kept narrowly
6. SimilarityLike produces like; an accurate image of a thing gives control over it.Models help to the degree that their structure matches the target: scale models, maps, simulations. Looking alike is not sharing a cause, which is the essay’s first rule.Kept narrowly
7. ContagionThings once in contact keep interacting after they separate.Contact transfers material, so contact leaves traces: pathogens, and the trace evidence that forensic work relies on (Locard’s exchange principle). A continuing link after separation is not kept. Vaccination looks like contagion and is not (Note 8).Kept narrowly
8. Positive AttractionLike attracts like; what you put out comes back in kind.People do tend to form ties with similar people (McPherson, Smith-Lovin, and Cook 2001), and expectations have small self-fulfilling effects (Section III, Expecting). No force returns what is sent.Kept narrowly
9. Negative AttractionLike attracts unlike; opposites attract.No general law. Across 313 studies, actual similarity predicted attraction (r = .47), and perceived similarity mattered more once people knew each other (Montoya, Horton, and Kirchner 2008). Complementary pairings happen, and the folk saying survives on the cases that confirm it.Not kept
10. NamesKnowing the true name of a thing gives complete control over it.A name lets people describe, compare, and contest a harm, as sexual harassment did (Section III, Naming). It gave standing, not control, and the institutions did the work.Kept narrowly
11. Words of PowerCertain words change the internal and external realities of those who say them.Some words change a person’s status inside institutions that honour them: I do, guilty, you’re hired (Austin 1962). Outside the institution they do nothing.Kept narrowly
12. PersonificationAny phenomenon may be treated as a being.Law can treat a non-human thing as a legal person: corporations, and the Whanganui River under the Te Awa Tupua Act (Section III). It is an instrument of standing, not a claim about what the thing is.Kept narrowly
13. InvocationOne can communicate internally with entities inside or outside oneself.Not testable as stated. The ordinary world has inner speech and imagined listeners. That shows the experience exists, not that the entities do.Not testable
14. EvocationOne can communicate externally with entities inside or outside oneself.Not testable as stated. Reports of such encounters can be studied as reports, using the same three-way split as Jung’s beetle: the report, the event, the explanation (Section IV).Not testable
15. IdentificationEnough association with another being lets one become that being.The sense of owning a body part is more flexible than it feels: the rubber hand illusion (Section III, Seeing). Becoming another being is not kept.Kept narrowly
16. Infinite DataThe number of phenomena to be known is infinite.Not testable, and harmless. Research has never run out of questions, but that is evidence about the past, not a proof about the future.Not testable
17. Finite SensesEvery sense mechanism is limited in range and in type of data.Holds as written: magenta has no wavelength of its own, the ear supplies the missing fundamental, and a hidden hand can feel like a rubber one (Section III, Seeing). The step from an unseen thing to spirits is not licensed.Kept as written
18. Personal UniversesEveryone lives in, and perhaps creates, a universe not identical to anyone else’s.Perceptual worlds differ: no two people see quite the same rainbow (Section II), and animals live in perceptual worlds of their own (von Uexküll 1934). The overlap is large because bodies and physics are shared. The claim that people create the universe is not kept.Kept narrowly
19. Infinite UniversesThe number of universes that existing phenomena could be arranged into is infinite.Not testable. This is a claim about possible arrangements, not about anything observed.Not testable
20. PragmatismA belief that helps you survive and reach your goals is true.It works as a rule for choosing tools. It fails as a test of truth: the Mozart effect and learning styles sold well on small or unshown effects (Section II).Not kept
21. True FalsehoodsA nonsensical idea may be true if it works in context.Useful fictions exist: all models are wrong, and some are useful (Box 1976). Usefulness in a stated context is not truth, and a paradox is not evidence. The invented bus scene in Section I says that it is invented.Kept narrowly
22. PolarityAny pattern splits into opposing patterns, each containing the other’s essence.Any dichotomy can be constructed, so the law cannot be wrong and does not say anything. It describes a habit of description, not the world.Not kept
23. SynthesisCombining opposing patterns produces something truer than either.Sometimes. Nothing guarantees it, and a compromise between a true claim and a false one is not truer than the true one.Not kept
24. Dynamic BalanceTo survive and gain power, keep every aspect of your universe in balance with every other.Balancing feedback keeps organisms and ecosystems stable (Meadows 2008). “Every aspect” cannot be balanced at once. Trade-offs are the rule.Kept narrowly
25. PerversityIf anything can go wrong, it will, in the most annoying way.Given enough chances, possible failures occur (the counting argument in Section IV), and annoyances are remembered better than non-events. “In the most annoying way” is selection.Kept narrowly
26. UnityEvery phenomenon is linked to every other.Not testable as stated. It becomes conspiracy thinking only with three more steps: the links are intended, the intention is hidden, and the account is sealed (Barkun; Section IV).Not testable

Sources

Sources already cited in the essay’s notes are not repeated. Others:

  1. Austin, J. L. (1962). How to Do Things with Words. Oxford: Clarendon Press. Verify
  2. Nisbett, R. E., and Wilson, T. D. (1977). Telling more than we can know: Verbal reports on mental processes. Psychological Review 84(3): 231–259.
  3. McPherson, M., Smith-Lovin, L., and Cook, J. M. (2001). Birds of a feather: Homophily in social networks. Annual Review of Sociology 27: 415–444.
  4. Montoya, R. M., Horton, R. S., and Kirchner, J. (2008). Is actual similarity necessary for attraction? A meta-analysis of actual and perceived similarity. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships 25(6): 889–922.
  5. Box, G. E. P. (1976). Science and statistics. Journal of the American Statistical Association 71(356): 791–799.
  6. Meadows, D. H. (2008). Thinking in Systems: A Primer. White River Junction, VT: Chelsea Green. Verify
  7. von Uexküll, J. (1934). Streifzüge durch die Umwelten von Tieren und Menschen. Berlin: Springer. Verify
  8. Locard’s exchange principle (Edmond Locard, early twentieth century): no single primary citation has been chosen yet. Verify

Return to the essay: Sufficiently Familiar Magic