The Sapiens Terminus Pattern

Hominin extirpation, megafaunal collapse, steppe conquest and colonization as one pattern of violent replacement

Working hypothesis. Institutions are patterns, and patterns need upkeep. Replacement is what happens when a new pattern is installed by force and the old one is denied the upkeep it needs to recover. This page wagers that four episodes, spread across 50,000 years, share that structure. It is a wager, not a finding. The evidence is strong in places and circumstantial in others, and the Receipts drawer at the foot of the page says which is which.

1. The Terminus Event

History likes the word transition. It sounds like a lane change: signal, merge, carry on, nobody hurt. The archaeological, genetic and paleoecological records describe something less courteous, and this page gives it a less courteous name.

A Terminus Event is an episode of rapid, directional replacement: an incumbent biological or cultural order severed and overwritten by arrivals carrying a stronger competitive package. It has three features:

  1. Rapid replacement: the incumbent population or guild goes far faster than the stability before it took to build.
  2. Asymmetrical violence: the encounter turns on a gross disparity in force, whether weapons, pathogens or the destruction of a niche.
  3. Institutional installation: the arrivals install a durable operating system, a suite of technologies, ideologies and institutions that blocks recovery and props up the new hierarchy.

Four cases put the pattern on trial: the disappearance of Neanderthals and Denisovans; the collapse of Pleistocene megafauna in the Americas after human arrival; the genetic turnover of Bronze Age Europe by the Yamnaya; and the European colonization of the Americas.

The wager, built from radiocarbon dates, ancient DNA, forensic anthropology and Earth system science, is that all four run on one conquest logic: expansion by removing competitors and rebuilding the living world around the newcomer’s needs. The arriving party rarely asks to share the kitchen. It renovates.

2. Deep time: the Sapiens Terminus and the extirpation of archaic hominins

For hundreds of thousands of years Eurasia supported several kinds of human, Neanderthals in the west and Denisovans in the east. By about 40,000 years ago the roster had shrunk to one. Was that passive replacement driven by climate, or active extirpation driven by what modern humans brought with them? Both answers have serious defenders. Only one lets the survivors off the hook, which is not evidence against it, but is worth noticing.

2.1 Mapping the replacement in space and time

The dates have tightened, and the older picture of long coexistence in quiet refuges has not survived the tightening. The “Ebro Frontier” hypothesis held that Neanderthals endured in southern Iberia for millennia after vanishing from the north, sheltered behind the Ebro valley. Better dating of bone collagen has moved those supposedly late sites back to about 45,000 years ago or earlier, in line with extinctions elsewhere. The last refuge, it turns out, was a dating problem.

That synchrony suggests a continental event rather than slow attrition. Across Europe, Neanderthal Mousterian toolkits end between about 41,000 and 39,000 years ago, as the Aurignacian, the material signature of modern humans, spreads.

First contact was not a single afternoon. It produced a mosaic lasting 2,600 to 5,400 years, and it was anything but stable. At Mandrin Cave in France, H. sapiens entered Neanderthal territory around 54,000 years ago and was pushed out again before the final wave. The frontier moved both ways. The ending was contingent, not written in advance.

2.2 Forensic evidence of violence between species

The “peaceful replacement” view rests on the absence of mass graves. Absence of evidence is being asked to carry a great deal of furniture there. Individual skeletons tell a colder story, though there are few of them and each can be read more than one way.

Shanidar 3, a Neanderthal from Iraq (c. 47,000–40,000 BP), took a penetrating wound to the left ninth rib. Experiments on pig carcasses show that the clean incision, with no rib fracture, does not fit the heavy thrusting spears Neanderthals used. It fits a low-mass, high-velocity projectile: a dart thrown with a spear-thrower, or an arrow. The 45-degree downward track implies a shot from a distance.

If so, H. sapiens could strike from beyond the reach of a thrusting spear. Between a close-quarters fighter and a ranged attacker, stand-off capability decides. Bravery is a poor answer to a weapon that arrives before its owner does.

The St. Césaire Neanderthal (France, c. 36,000 BP) carries a healed skull fracture made by a sharp implement. Violence within his own group cannot be ruled out; the context, a young adult male in the Châtelperronian overlap, fits conflict between populations. What is not in doubt is that he healed, which means someone looked after him. If this was a Terminus, it was resisted by cohesive communities, not by fragile loners waiting to be swept aside.

2.3 The biological and social operating system

Differences in social organization and biological compatibility likely sped up the replacement, working as soft weapons alongside the hard ones. The first is a network gap. Genomes from the “Thorin” lineage in France show Neanderthals who stayed genetically isolated for 50,000 years while living a few days’ walk from other groups. Early Upper Palaeolithic H. sapiens kept mating and information networks running across vast distances.

In a crisis that decides things. An isolated band hit by famine, disease or conflict had no reserve to call on. Modern humans could draw kin from distant territories to replace local losses, a demographic pump that kept frontier numbers high and eventually swamped the smaller Neanderthal enclaves. That last step is inference. It is the inference an actuary would make.

The second is a proposed genetic barrier. A 2025 preprint, not yet peer reviewed, points to an incompatibility in the PIEZO1 gene, carried by a protein on red blood cells. The authors propose that a mismatch between a Neanderthal mother and a hybrid fetus could have compromised the pregnancy: fewer viable hybrids, limited and often one-directional gene flow, two populations that never fused. Until review has had its say, it is a promising idea sitting in a waiting room.

2.4 The first Terminus

On this evidence, the Neanderthal disappearance looks less like an accident of weather and more like a Terminus Event: projectile weapons, a sturdier social operating system in long-distance networks, and a probable edge in reproductive viability. A rival hominin species was extirpated, and survives as a 1–4% genetic echo in the survivors.

History is written by the winners. The losers, it turns out, are written into them.

3. The Pleistocene Terminus: megafaunal collapse in the Americas

The human colonization of the Americas is, on this reading, the clearest case of a super-predator arriving on a continent whose large animals had evolved in complete isolation from hominin hunters. The Late Pleistocene extinction that followed removed more than 75% of large mammal genera in the Western Hemisphere.

3.1 Chronological disruption: the pre-Clovis reality

For decades the “Clovis First” model offered a tidy story: a Blitzkrieg colonization around 13,000 BP, human arrival lining up neatly against the extinction of mammoths, mastodons and ground sloths. Tidy stories are the first casualties of new data. The timeline has broken; the link between arrival and extinction has held, in a more complicated shape.

Human footprints at White Sands National Park, dated to 23,000–21,000 BP, put people in North America during the Last Glacial Maximum, about 10,000 years before Clovis. That opens a coexistence lag the simple Blitzkrieg model cannot swallow. The same footprints show what the lag looked like: people tracking giant ground sloths, sloth tracks swerving in evasive turns. Even at low densities, humans registered as a threat. Early populations were too small and too lightly equipped to bring a continent down. The lag was the incubation period.

3.2 The mechanism of collapse: technology and ecology

If people arrived 23,000 years ago, why did the megafauna last until 13,000? The likely answer is more people, plus specialized killing technology.

The Clovis techno-complex (c. 13,000 BP) appears alongside the final extinction pulse. Experimental modelling challenges the view of Clovis points as simple projectile tips: their fluted, heavy design suggests use as pikes braced against the ground, letting a charging animal’s own momentum drive the point home. In that model the technique cut the cost and risk of hunting proboscideans sharply, converting low-level predation into a “hyper-disease” slow-breeding megafauna could not survive.

The sediment keeps its own minutes. Sporormiella, a fungus that needs the guts of large herbivores to reproduce, falls sharply at sites such as Page-Ladson in Florida around 12,600 BP, marking the functional extinction of local megaherds. At well-studied sites the decline comes before the major changes in vegetation and fire.

The order matters. If climate were the driver, habitat loss should come first and the animals second. Instead the herbivores go first, then hardwood growth and more charcoal as the landscape fills with uneaten fuel. That sequence is the fingerprint of a predator-driven trophic cascade. The fingerprint is smudged: the spore proxy is itself debated.

3.3 Comparative analysis: the naivety factor

Why did African and Asian megafauna survive while American and Australian megafauna did not? The deciding variable appears to be evolutionary experience. African megafauna evolved alongside hominins for millions of years. As human hunting improved by increments, from scavenging to thrusting spears to projectiles, prey developed behavioural defences: wariness, aggression, nocturnal habits. American megafauna met H. sapiens as a finished super-predator, and likely did not read small bipedal apes as lethal until they were within killing range. Africa’s animals had a long apprenticeship in human company. America’s met the finished product. Lemoine and colleagues (2023) found that human arrival predicts extinction magnitude better than any climate variable, which is what a missing apprenticeship looks like in the numbers.

3.4 The ecological Terminus

The megafaunal extinction was a Terminus Event for the whole Pleistocene biome:

  • Nutrient cycling stopped: without large herbivores, nutrients no longer travelled in dung from floodplains to uplands, and the soil grew poorer.
  • The vegetation flipped: with mammoths gone, dark boreal forest replaced light-reflecting steppe-tundra, which may have sped up regional warming.
  • The predators followed: losing the herbivores forced the co-extinction of their specialized predators, the American lion (Panthera atrox) and the sabre-toothed cat (Smilodon fatalis) among them.

The “wilderness” later European explorers described as a pristine Eden was, on this reading, a recovering ecosystem still reeling from the loss of its keystone species. Eden is the name newcomers give a place whose history they have not asked about.

4. The Steppe Terminus: the Yamnaya expansion and the patriarchal-militant package

Around 3000 BCE a large migration from the Pontic-Caspian Steppe redrew the genetic and cultural map of Europe. The Yamnaya, carrying a new package of mobility and social organization, moved west and replaced the Neolithic farmers who had lived there for millennia. This “Kurgan imposition” is the prototype of the institutional Terminus.

4.1 The genetics of replacement

Few Holocene turnovers match it. Ancient DNA shows the Corded Ware culture, emerging around 2900 BCE, drew about 75% of its ancestry from the Yamnaya. In Britain the Bell Beaker culture, a western extension of Steppe influence, produced about 90% replacement of the local Neolithic gene pool within a few centuries.

The replacement was strongly sex-biased. Neolithic Y-chromosome lineages such as haplogroup G2a were almost entirely replaced by Steppe-derived lineages, mainly R1a and R1b. The maternal line shows much more continuity.

Geneticists draw the result as star-shaped phylogenies: a few male lineages spreading fast across the whole reproductive landscape. That implies extreme stratification and polygyny, incoming Steppe men monopolizing reproductive access and Neolithic men removed from the gene pool. Later accounts would call this a migration. The chromosomes describe a hostile takeover.

4.2 The patriarchal-militant package

The Yamnaya advantage was not one invention but a bundle of institutions and technology working as a conquest operating system. Like much successful software, it came with a youth program.

The koryos. On this reconstruction the engine was the koryos, Proto-Indo-European for “war band”: landless adolescent males initiated into warrior status through rites often involving wolf or dog symbolism, serving as a mobile vanguard rewarded for raiding and for taking territory where they could found households of their own. The hard evidence for the rites is later, Late Bronze Age dog sacrifices at Krasnosamarskoe, so reading the koryos back into the Yamnaya is a reconstruction, if a persuasive one. The bookkeeping is grim either way: every generation produced a new cohort of young men with nothing to inherit and a licence to acquire.

The wagon and the horse. These turned the steppe itself into a supply base. Wagons carried water and stores into grasslands river-bound farmers could not use. That bought strategic depth: strike a distant target, fall back into the grass, project power at a range settled farmers could not match.

Ideological hierarchy. The kurgan burial tradition reflects a society organized around rank and male violence. Neolithic megalithic tombs were communal; Yamnaya burials are individual and glorify the armed male warrior. The ideology validated the dominance of “the rightful ones,” a root concept in Indo-European self-designation, over subordinate populations. A people who name themselves the rightful ones have settled the argument before anyone else arrives.

4.3 Violence and the vacuum of disease

Was the replacement purely violent? Some evidence has Yersinia pestis, the plague bacterium, spreading into Europe from the steppe alongside or just before the Yamnaya. A “virgin soil” epidemic could have hollowed out Neolithic populations and left a vacuum to fill.

Disease alone does not explain the structure of what followed. The erasure of male lineages and the imposition of Steppe norms in language, burial and descent indicate that the Yamnaya did not simply move into empty houses. They kept the societies already there from recovering.

At Koszyce in Poland, 15 members of an extended Globular Amphora family were killed by blows to the head. The grave is a snapshot of the violence at the friction points between the Steppe frontier and the Neolithic world.

5. The Colonial Terminus: European arrival in the Americas

European arrival in 1492 is the best-documented Terminus Event, combining the biological devastation of the Pleistocene extinctions with the institutional imposition of the Steppe conquests. It is the pattern in its most complete form: a replacement so total it changed the chemistry of the atmosphere.

5.1 The Great Dying: a demographic singularity

Current estimates put the pre-contact Indigenous population of the Americas at about 60.5 million. By 1600 CE it had fallen to roughly 6 million: a collapse of 90%. Nine people in ten.

The depopulation left a measurable mark on the Earth system. About 56 million hectares of Indigenous farmland, roughly the area of France, was abandoned and went back to forest. The regrowth drew down about 7.4 petagrams of carbon and lowered global CO₂ by 7–10 ppm, contributing to the coldest phase of the Little Ice Age in the early 17th century.

The Colonial Terminus was a human catastrophe and a geological event: the deaths of millions are recorded in Antarctic ice cores. Few crimes leave evidence at the scale of a planet. This one did, and it still took four centuries to read.

5.2 The colonial operating system

Disease, meaning smallpox, measles and influenza, was the main agent of death. Institutions made the Terminus stick.

The encomienda is often compared to European feudalism, a comparison that flatters it. Feudalism bound lord and serf, of one religion and broadly one community, to the land, with obligations running both ways however unequal. The encomienda was a grant of people, explicitly racialized as distinct and inferior, to a conqueror for the purpose of extraction. It dismantled Indigenous political economies, redirected the labour surplus to the metropole, and blocked recovery by working survivors to death. It was the legal device that turned a population into a resource.

Law, here, was not the opposite of violence. It was violence with a filing system.

Ecological imperialism. The Terminus also arrived on four legs. Old World cattle, pigs and sheep ravaged ecosystems unadapted to hard-hoofed grazers, with pigs going ahead as a biological vanguard, destroying Indigenous crops. European weeds, rats and pathogens colonized the biota, making the land hospitable to the invader and hostile to the people already living there. The Columbian Exchange was an exchange in roughly the sense that a mugging is.

5.3 Resistance and the limits of the Terminus

Unlike the extinction of the Neanderthals, the Colonial Terminus was incomplete. Indigenous resistance marks the limits of the replacement model, and is the part of this page most worth remembering.

In what is now Chile, the Mapuche resisted Spanish conquest for more than 300 years, on a decentralized structure that offered no single head to cut off and on rapid adoption of the invader’s own package, especially the horse and iron weapons. Mounted warfare levelled the field and forced the Spanish into the parlamentos, treaties recognizing Mapuche sovereignty. The empire that came to install an operating system ended up negotiating with one.

In 1680 the Pueblo nations of New Mexico staged a coordinated uprising that expelled the Spanish for 12 years. Led by Po’pay, it was a revitalization movement aimed squarely at undoing the Colonial Terminus: churches burned, baptisms washed off, Spanish crops destroyed. The Spanish returned, but the revolt forced a revision of the operating system, and a more tolerant regime allowed Pueblo culture to survive to the present. That tolerance was not a gift. It was a concession, won.

6. Comparative synthesis: the structure of the Terminus pattern

Set side by side, the four cases read less like isolated accidents than like repeated runs of one mode of expansion across 50,000 years. That is the claim. A resemblance is not a proof. It is a reason to go looking for one.

6.1 The scale of replacement

The clock speeds up. Roughly: 2,000–5,000 years to replace the archaic hominins, 1,000–2,000 for the megafaunal collapse, 200–500 for the Steppe turnover, about 100 for the Great Dying. The comparison table is in the Receipts drawer.

6.2 Structural commonalities

  1. The package advantage: projectiles and large social networks (Sapiens); Clovis points and fire (Pleistocene); horses, wheels and the koryos (Yamnaya); germs, steel, the encomienda and theology (Colonial). Each bundle extracts energy more efficiently than the incumbent, and more destructively.
  2. Asymmetrical violence: never between peers. Shanidar 3 shot from a distance, on the best reading; megafauna impaled on weapons they did not understand, in the pike model; Neolithic farmers overrun by mobile war bands; Indigenous Americans killed by pathogens they could not fight. Nobody wins a fair fight here, because nobody offers one. In the terms of Human Self-Domestication Syndrome, this is proactive aggression: planned, coordinated, aimed outward by a species that had learned to keep its temper at home.
  3. The ghost population: the conquered rarely vanish outright; they are absorbed or pushed to the margins in ways that erase a distinct identity. The star-shaped Yamnaya phylogenies are the sharpest version: defeated men removed, women absorbed into the invaders’ reproductive system.
  4. Ecological resetting: a Terminus is not a change of management. Removing ecosystem engineers, mammoths or Indigenous farmers, pushes the biosphere into a new state that favours the invader’s way of making a living.

6.3 The acceleration of the Terminus

The four events trace a trajectory, and it runs from bodies to bureaucracy:

  • Deep time: biological and slow, running on “wetware” differences and competition for a niche.
  • Prehistory: technological, with Clovis and the Bronze Age. The pace rises to centuries.
  • History: institutional. There is no need to replace every individual if their culture and economy can be replaced instead. Colonization achieved a demographic Terminus through disease; its lasting power was the institutional Terminus: the state, the market, the church.

The later the Terminus, the less it needs to replace the people. It only needs to own what happens to them next.

6.4 How this pattern could be wrong

A pattern that can swallow every counterexample is not a pattern. It is a mood. This one has plenty of ways to lose. Four cases that fit cannot say how often the fit occurs. If the herbivores turn out not to go first, if the spore proxy fails, if the Shanidar wound fits something other than a projectile, if the PIEZO1 preprint does not survive review, or if the Steppe turnover proves to be mostly plague, the wager shrinks accordingly. And if the four cases resemble each other mainly because this page describes them in one vocabulary, it has found a metaphor, not a mechanism. The Receipts drawer sets out what each case can bear.

7. The Terminus as the Anthropocene filter

The wager of this page is that the Terminus Event is not an aberration but a habit: the mechanism by which Homo sapiens, and particular cultures within it, have repeatedly reorganized the planet’s biological and social complexity around themselves.

That sits badly with the official story of history as a melting pot, a slow accumulation of progress, or a marketplace of ideas in which the better ones simply won. The record reads more like a series of hostile takeovers, each followed by a press release. Every new order announces itself as civilization arriving. The previous order is reclassified as wilderness, prehistory or a regrettable demographic event. Diversity goes into the filter and comes out much reduced, and the success story is written up by whoever is left holding the pen.

Every new order announces itself as civilization arriving. The previous order is reclassified as wilderness.

This is the same move The Copernican Sequence traces in cosmology: each time the evidence displaces the species from the centre, the species relocates the centre. Neanderthals become a side branch. Megafauna become climate casualties. The Yamnaya become “a migration.” 1492 becomes “an encounter.” The epicycles keep turning so the invader never has to.

The incomplete Colonial Terminus, marked by the survival and resurgence of Indigenous peoples, shows the pattern can be resisted. The Mapuche and the Pueblo nations did not wait for the arc of history to bend. They bent it by hand.

The danger has not gone away. It has gone global. Humanity is now both invader and incumbent, running the same operating system on the only continent left, which is all of them. The resetting that once cleared ground for the next arrival now threatens the arrival itself. For the first time, the invader can read its own fingerprints in the ice, and has convened a series of annual conferences to discuss whether the fingerprints are really there.

The first discipline, as Against Drift puts it, is to see the real. Here that means naming the Terminus while it is still running, and refusing the transition story before someone else gets to write it about us.

Name the pattern. Read the operating system. Refuse the press release.


Receipts: evidence tier, comparison table and limits

Evidence tier: Hypothesis. One argument across four cases, with evidence that is strong in places and contested in others. Evidence Protocol · Theme Explorer

Comparison of the four cases

FeatureSapiens Terminus (hominins)Pleistocene Terminus (megafauna)Steppe Terminus (Yamnaya)Colonial Terminus (Americas)
Time to replacement~2,000–5,000 years (mosaic)~1,000–2,000 years (Clovis window)~200–500 years (genetic turnover)~100 years (Great Dying)
Demographic impact100% extinction of incumbents>75% extinction of genera~75–90% replacement of male lineages~90% population collapse
Primary mechanismCompetitive exclusion / projectilesOverkill / trophic cascadeMilitarized migration / social dominanceDisease / institutional extraction
Ecological impactNiche monopolyVegetation shift / fire regimesDeforestation / pasture expansionGlobal CO₂ drop / reforestation
“Software” installedUpper Paleolithic cultureClovis technologyIndo-European language / patriarchyChristianity / capitalism / racial caste

What the evidence permits, case by case

  • Sapiens Terminus. The chronology is well supported: revised radiocarbon dates collapse the late Iberian refuge, and Mousterian assemblages end across Europe around 41,000–39,000 BP. The violence evidence is two individuals, Shanidar 3 and St. Césaire, and both admit rival readings: a projectile wound versus another trauma, and intergroup versus intragroup conflict. The demographic pump is an inference from network structure, not a measurement. The PIEZO1 incompatibility is a 2025 preprint that has not been peer reviewed and should not be relied on. Falsifier: a securely dated, substantial late Neanderthal population after the Aurignacian spread, or a re-analysis that removes the projectile reading of Shanidar 3, would weaken the case.
  • Pleistocene Terminus. The White Sands footprints (23,000–21,000 BP) are themselves contested on dating grounds, and they lengthen rather than shorten the coexistence window the overkill model has to explain. The Clovis pike model comes from experimental reconstruction, not from a kill site that records the technique. The Sporormiella spore record is a proxy whose reliability is debated. Falsifier: if megaherbivore decline turned out to follow rather than precede vegetation and fire change at well-studied sites, the predator-driven cascade would lose its main support.
  • Steppe Terminus. The ancient DNA is the strongest evidence on the page: the ancestry proportions and the sex bias in the lineages are measured, not inferred. What is inferred is the cause. The koryos is a linguistic and comparative reconstruction whose hard archaeological support, the Krasnosamarskoe dog sacrifices, is Late Bronze Age and therefore later than the expansion it is used to explain. Falsifier: if plague turned out to account for the Neolithic collapse on its own, the conquest reading would reduce to an arrival into an emptied landscape.
  • Colonial Terminus. The documentary and demographic record is the best of the four; the population estimates and the atmospheric signature are themselves modelled quantities carrying wide uncertainty. The institutional argument, that the encomienda blocked recovery rather than merely accompanying it, is an interpretation of the legal record. Falsifier: a reconstruction in which the CO₂ drop is fully explained by causes other than American land abandonment would remove the Earth system leg of the case.

Scope, rivals and limits

The page argues a pattern, not a law. Four cases selected because they resemble each other cannot establish how often the resemblance occurs, and the selection is not a sample. The standing rivals are climate-driven extinction for the first two cases, epidemic collapse for the third and fourth, and the general objection that a vocabulary shared across 50,000 years may be doing the unifying work by itself. Nothing here licenses any claim about the inherent character of any living population, and nothing here treats the outcome as inevitable: the Colonial Terminus was resisted, incompletely reversed and is still being contested.

Voice revision 2026-09-17. This revision changed register and moved the apparatus into this drawer. It did not change any claim, grade or falsifier.

Sources used

  1. Wood, R. E., et al. 2013. “Radiocarbon dating casts doubt on the late chronology of the Middle to Upper Palaeolithic transition in southern Iberia.” PNAS 110 (8): 2781–86. doi.org
  2. Higham, T., et al. 2014. “The timing and spatiotemporal patterning of Neanderthal disappearance.” Nature 512: 306–09. doi.org
  3. Slimak, L., et al. 2022. “Modern human incursion into Neanderthal territories 54,000 years ago at Mandrin, France.” Science Advances 8 (6): eabj9496. doi.org
  4. Churchill, S. E., et al. 2009. “Shanidar 3 Neandertal rib puncture wound and Paleolithic weaponry.” Journal of Human Evolution 57 (2): 163–78. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
  5. Zollikofer, C. P. E., et al. 2002. “Evidence for interpersonal violence in the St. Césaire Neanderthal.” PNAS 99 (9): 6444–48. doi.org
  6. Spikins, P., et al. 2018. “Calculated or caring? Neanderthal healthcare in social context.” World Archaeology 50 (3): 384–403. eprints.whiterose.ac.uk
  7. Slimak, L., et al. 2024. “Long genetic and social isolation in Neanderthals before their extinction.” Cell Genomics 4 (9). cell.com
  8. Sikora, M., et al. 2017. “Ancient genomes show social and reproductive behavior of early Upper Paleolithic foragers.” Science 358: 659–62. doi.org
  9. Makhro, A., et al. 2025. “A maternal-fetal PIEZO1 incompatibility as a barrier to Neanderthal-modern human admixture.” bioRxiv preprint, not peer reviewed. doi.org
  10. Bennett, M. R., et al. 2021. “Evidence of humans in North America during the Last Glacial Maximum.” Science 373: 1528–31; see also Pigati, J. S., et al. 2023. “Independent age estimates resolve the controversy of ancient human footprints at White Sands.” Science 382: 73–75. doi.org
  11. Bustos, D., et al. 2018. “Footprints preserve terminal Pleistocene hunt? Human-sloth interactions in North America.” Science Advances 4 (4): eaar7621. doi.org
  12. Byram, R. S., K. G. Lightfoot, and J. U. Sunseri. 2024. “Clovis points and foreshafts under braced weapon compression: Modeling Pleistocene megafauna encounters with a lithic pike.” PLOS ONE 19 (8): e0307996. doi.org
  13. Halligan, J. J., et al. 2016. “Pre-Clovis occupation 14,550 years ago at the Page-Ladson site, Florida, and the peopling of the Americas.” Science Advances 2 (5): e1600375. doi.org
  14. Gill, J. L., et al. 2009. “Pleistocene megafaunal collapse, novel plant communities, and enhanced fire regimes in North America.” Science 326: 1100–03. doi.org
  15. “The spore conundrum: Does a dung fungus decline signal humans’ arrival in the Eastern United States?” (critique of the Sporormiella proxy). researchgate.net
  16. Sandom, C., et al. 2014. “Global late Quaternary megafauna extinctions linked to humans, not climate change.” Proceedings of the Royal Society B 281: 20133254. doi.org
  17. Lemoine, R. T., R. Buitenwerf, and J.-C. Svenning. 2023. “Megafauna extinctions in the late-Quaternary are linked to human range expansion, not climate change.” Anthropocene 44: 100403. doi.org
  18. Malhi, Y., et al. 2016. “Megafauna and ecosystem function from the Pleistocene to the Anthropocene.” PNAS 113 (4): 838–46. doi.org
  19. Ripple, W. J., and B. Van Valkenburgh. 2010. “Linking top-down forces to the Pleistocene megafaunal extinctions.” BioScience 60 (7): 516–26. academic.oup.com
  20. Haak, W., et al. 2015. “Massive migration from the steppe was a source for Indo-European languages in Europe.” Nature 522: 207–11. doi.org
  21. Olalde, I., et al. 2018. “The Beaker phenomenon and the genomic transformation of northwest Europe.” Nature 555: 190–96. doi.org
  22. Goldberg, A., et al. 2017. “Ancient X chromosomes reveal contrasting sex bias in Neolithic and Bronze Age Eurasian migrations.” PNAS 114 (10): 2657–62. doi.org
  23. Anthony, D. W., and D. R. Brown. 2017. “The dogs of war: A Bronze Age initiation ritual in the Russian steppes.” Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 48: 134–48. sciencedirect.com
  24. Anthony, D. W. 2007. The Horse, the Wheel, and Language: How Bronze-Age Riders from the Eurasian Steppes Shaped the Modern World. Princeton University Press.
  25. Kristiansen, K., et al. 2017. “Re-theorising mobility and the formation of culture and language among the Corded Ware Culture in Europe.” Antiquity 91 (356): 334–47. cambridge.org
  26. Rasmussen, S., et al. 2015. “Early divergent strains of Yersinia pestis in Eurasia 5,000 years ago.” Cell 163 (3): 571–82. doi.org
  27. Schroeder, H., et al. 2019. “Unraveling ancestry, kinship, and violence in a Late Neolithic mass grave.” PNAS 116 (22): 10705–10. doi.org
  28. Koch, A., C. Brierley, M. M. Maslin, and S. L. Lewis. 2019. “Earth system impacts of the European arrival and Great Dying in the Americas after 1492.” Quaternary Science Reviews 207: 13–36. doi.org
  29. Yeager, T. J. 1995. “Encomienda or slavery? The Spanish Crown’s choice of labor organization in sixteenth-century Spanish America.” Journal of Economic History 55 (4): 842–59. cambridge.org
  30. Patterson, O. 1982. Slavery and Social Death: A Comparative Study. Harvard University Press.
  31. Melville, E. G. K. 1994. A Plague of Sheep: Environmental Consequences of the Conquest of Mexico. Cambridge University Press.
  32. Crosby, A. W. 1986. Ecological Imperialism: The Biological Expansion of Europe, 900–1900. Cambridge University Press.
  33. Padden, R. C. 1957. “Cultural change and military resistance in Araucanian Chile, 1550–1730.” Southwestern Journal of Anthropology 13 (1): 103–21. doi.org
  34. Gilder Lehrman Institute of American History. “The Pueblo Revolt.” gilderlehrman.org
  35. Liebmann, M. 2012. Revolt: An Archaeological History of Pueblo Resistance and Revitalization in 17th Century New Mexico. University of Arizona Press.

Further reading

  • Lewis, S. L., and M. A. Maslin. 2015. “Defining the Anthropocene.” Nature 519: 171–80. doi.org
  • Reich, D. 2018. Who We Are and How We Got Here. Pantheon.
  • Martin, P. S. 2005. Twilight of the Mammoths. University of California Press.
  • Rascovan, N., et al. 2019. “Emergence and spread of basal lineages of Yersinia pestis during the Neolithic decline.” Cell 176 (1–2): 295–305. doi.org

← Human Self-Domestication Syndrome  |  Next: The Double Bank →