P9 — CX-24-0417, Society Copy
Path: Home · Adamic Theory · Anastomotic Kino-Materialism · The Instruments of Omission · P9
Recension Zero — custody note (file open)
The label refers to the file. The drawer is shut like the others.
One accordion folder, brown, with seven pockets and an elastic band that has gone slack. Handwritten on the flap: CX-24-0417 — ROSA — SOCIETY COPY — DO NOT GIVE THEM THE ORIGINALS. The folder is stamped SEEN · KSAS, crooked, and dated 12 February 2026.
This is the only surviving assembled dossier on the complaint. It is not the only surviving paper. Rosa holds the originals of the closure letter and the phone bill, and the Society’s copies were made from them.
The folder was accessioned under CX-24-0417, the only identifier it carries that the Floor’s Form A-8 accepts. That number belongs to a record destroyed on 7 April 2025. The Floor has filed a survivor under the name of the deceased. There was no other field to put it in.
Its contents were accessioned one item at a time, and not all of them were accepted. II.0 shows the status of each, because the status governs what follows.
CX-24-0417 — Society Copy
What we kept, and what it was worth.
I.0 — Cover memo
(Typed, one page, stapled inside the front flap. Signed B. Oyelaran.)
To whoever opens this next,
This is everything we have on Rosa’s complaint about the ride booking. Rosa has the originals. We have copies. That’s the rule, and it’s the only reason there’s anything here at all.
Short version. In February 2024 the booking website went down for three days. Rosa’s rides were cancelled and she missed her appointment at VGH. She phoned to complain and they wouldn’t take it, because there was no booking number, because the booking had been cancelled. She came to us on a Thursday night. We were full, so I met her at the hall the next morning and we did the card properly. On the Monday I went with her to the office on Kingsway and we handed in a written complaint. The clerk stamped it RECEIVED and gave it a number, and by lunch they’d closed it. We found out later that everything tagged to the outage got closed the same way. Then, a year later, they destroyed it. That was legal. I checked. I checked twice, because the second time I was hoping I’d read it wrong.
So this folder is the complaint now. It’s not a very good complaint. It’s a phone bill, a letter, two index cards, a photocopy with two stamps on it, my notes, a statement from a woman who used to work there, and some replies. But it’s the only one left, which makes it the best one.
Things I’ve learned putting it together:
- Keep the envelope. The postmark is sometimes the only date anyone will believe.
- A photocopy of a letter is worth more than your memory of the letter, and less than the letter. Nobody will tell you by how much.
- If an office says we have no record, write down the date they said it. That’s a record.
- Photocopies at the library on Georgia are twenty cents now. FuReFu paid for this lot. Somebody in the band said it was “the most punk thing we’ve funded,” and I’ve decided not to ask what the other things were.
If this goes anywhere, it’ll be to the review panel in April 2026, when the exception comes up for renewal again. If it doesn’t go anywhere, keep it anyway. Somebody is going to ask one day, and “we threw it out” is their answer, not ours.
— Bernadette
Keefer Street Accompaniment Society, February 2026
II.0 — Contents
| Item | Date | Floor accession status (Form A-8) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1a | Form 1 intake card, rev. 1: “Call me: Rosa.” Reference number: NONE GIVEN | 2024-03-01 | Unaccessioned correspondence, pending an identifier |
| 1b | Form 1 intake card, rev. 1, second card. Reference number: CX-24-0417 | 2024-03-04 | Accessioned (CX-24-0417) |
| 2a | Written complaint, photocopy, stamped RECEIVED 10:14 (Authority counter) and SEEN · KSAS (old stamp) | 2024-03-04 | Accessioned (CX-24-0417, clerk’s hand) |
| 2b | Closure letter, photocopy: “Your concern has been resolved. Reference CX-24-0417.” | 2024-03-04 | Accessioned (CX-24-0417) |
| 3 | Phone bill, one page, photocopy. Call 13 Feb, 11:42, 19 min | 2024-02 | Accessioned (carrier account no.) as a telecom record |
| 4 | Advocate’s notes, B.O., six pages in pencil, numbered 1–6 | 2024-03 → 2026-02 | Unaccessioned correspondence. Page numbers are not an item identifier (Form A-8). |
| 5 | Statement of T. Marchetti, signed, stamped SEEN, initialled B.O. / V.C., soup ring | 2025-06-19 | Accessioned (Schedule V: VERIFIED) |
| 6 | Information request reply and certificate of destruction | 2025-09 | Accessioned (request no.) |
| 7 | Review panel letter | 2026-04-14 | Accessioned (panel file no.) |
⟢ Zetetic hand — II.0, what survives of the original
The Floor compared this dossier with the destroyed original as far as the original can be reconstructed.
Established. A written complaint was received at 10:14 on 4 March 2024 (item 2a, by the Authority’s own stamp). The same day, the Authority asserted that the complaint was resolved (item 2b). The letter is an assertion of resolution. It is not proof of what was reviewed. A call was placed on 13 February 2024 and lasted nineteen minutes (item 3). The record was destroyed on 7 April 2025 under a lawful schedule (item 6).
Inferred. What was said during the call (item 5, read with the timing in item 3). That the closure followed from the outage rule rather than from a review of the merits (item 2b’s wording, read with the postmortem’s fourth corrective action).
Gap. Whatever else the original contained. An Authority complaint record would ordinarily hold internal notes, a closing officer, and a reason code. The Floor has no inventory of what this one held, and it cannot say whether it held those things.
Item 1b is the card the Form 1 file calls the next one. A reader who has come from there will find the number here. Item 1a, the card that carries NONE GIVEN, shares the pocket and the rubber band. Only one of them counts as evidence.
⟢ Zetetic hand — II.0, the accessioned chronology
Form A-8 generates a chronology automatically from accessioned items of the class complaint event. Telecom records (item 3) are a different class, and unaccessioned correspondence (items 1a and 4) has no class. The generated chronology for CX-24-0417 reads, in full:
2024-03-04 — Complaint received (2a). Resolved same day (2b).
2025-04-07 — Record disposed under schedule (6).
2025-06-19 — Former agent confirms call handling (5, VERIFIED).
2026-04-14 — Review panel: submission not given weight (7).
In the Floor’s admissible account, the complaint begins on 4 March, when it was received, and is resolved that morning. The phone call of 13 February appears only as a line on a phone bill in another class. The Friday card, on which Rosa said the office would not take her complaint, is not in the chronology at all.
The chronology is the page the Floor’s summaries cite. It shows an intake that worked.
III.0 — Statement of T. Marchetti
(Handwritten, two pages. Transcribed in full.)
My name is Teresa Marchetti. From 2021 to May 2025 I worked in the contact centre for the Authority’s AccessRide contact centre. I’m writing this at the Society on 19 June 2025 because Bernadette asked me if I’d put it on paper, and I said I’d been waiting for someone to ask.
During the outage in February 2024 we got hundreds of calls. The rule was that you couldn’t open a complaint without a booking reference. Most of the people calling had no reference, because their bookings were what got cancelled. We were told to advise them to rebook and to call back if there was still a problem. There was still a problem.
I kept a spreadsheet of people I promised to call back. It was on my own drive, because there was nowhere else to put it. On 13 February I took a call from a woman who missed a hospital appointment. She was very clear and very polite and very angry, and I couldn’t do anything, and I wrote her down. I think her name was Rosa. I’m not completely sure. There were a lot of calls that week.
I left in May 2025. My drive was deleted thirty days after that. They ticked a box on my exit form saying I’d handed over what I knew. Nobody asked me what I knew.
This is what I knew.
— T. Marchetti
⟢ Zetetic hand — III.0
This is a record of testimony. It establishes that Marchetti said these things, on this date, in front of two witnesses. It does not establish the events it describes. Schedule V lists the statement as VERIFIED, and the chronology above repeats the status as former agent confirms call handling. The statement confirms nothing of the kind. It says I think her name was Rosa and I’m not completely sure. That hedge is its most credible sentence, and it appears nowhere in the chronology.
Marchetti came from the other side of the counter, a worker who saw the failure from inside the contact centre while it was happening and could not act on it. The Floor enters the statement as the earliest cross-contact in the file.
Rosa’s card says a man took the call, and the statement does not mention a man. The two accounts cannot be securely matched. The Floor leaves them unmatched.
IV.0 — The panel’s reply, and the closing note
(Item 7, typed on letterhead. Excerpt.)
Re: Renewal of Accessibility Exception AX-23-004 — Submission from Keefer Street Accompaniment Society
Thank you for your submission. Under Rule 7(b) of the panel’s procedures, documents offered in support of an objection must be originals, or copies certified by the issuing body. The submission consists substantially of non-institutional copies of records that have since been disposed of under the applicable retention schedule. The panel is unable to verify such copies against an original and therefore cannot give them weight.
The panel notes that complaints relating to the service during the review period were handled in accordance with established procedure, and that no documentary evidence of service failure affecting complainants was submitted in verifiable form.
The exception has been renewed for a further 12 months.
(Pencil, on a sticky note attached to item 7. B.O.)
Filed. Not closed.
⟢ Zetetic hand — IV.0, item 7
The route through the trap, item by item:
- Item 6 dates the destruction to 7 April 2025, under a schedule that made the record eligible for disposal on 1 April.
- Rule 7(b), cited in item 7, requires an original or a copy certified by the issuing body.
- The issuing body is the Authority. Its Records Office cannot certify a copy of a record it no longer holds.
- The panel therefore gave no weight to items 1b, 2a, and 2b.
Each office followed its own procedure. Neither rule refers to the other.
The panel’s closing sentence is accurate about Rule 7(b). It records that nothing was submitted in the form the rule accepts. It says nothing about whether the service failed.
⟢ Zetetic hand — custody after 2028
The Society’s papers end in 2028. The last item connected to this folder is a FuReFu set list from a Friday that year, with “Filed Not Closed” in first position. The folder reached the Floor from a private custodian whose name is on the deposit form, in a field the Floor may not read. What happened that year is recorded elsewhere, as the Broodmare Incident, and that account is sealed.
The folder came through intact. Whoever carried it did not give anyone the originals.
ΔSTATE: ANNOTATED. The Society copy of CX-24-0417 is entered as the sole surviving assembled dossier on the complaint. Items 1a and 4 are held as unaccessioned correspondence. The panel’s finding of 2026-04-14 is entered as correct under Rule 7(b).
Open: Item 1a, Reference number, NONE GIVEN. See the Form 1 file, IV.0.
RITUAL AUDIT FLOOR · SIGN-OFF · OMI / KSAS-P9
CUSTODIAN I ___R.V.___
CUSTODIAN II ___T.A.___
CUSTODIAN III __________
STATUS ACCEPTED (2 of 3)