P3 — KSAS Form 1, Case Intake Card

Path: Home · Adamic Theory · Anastomotic Kino-Materialism · The Instruments of Omission · P3

Recension Zero — custody note (file open)

The label refers to the file, which is open: audits do not close. The drawer itself is shut, like the others. A reader who has opened it anyway has, the Floor records, agreed to be delayed.

The Floor received two objects together, held by a bulldog clip that has been entered as a third.

The card. One index card, five by eight, rev. 4, printed on both sides and never filled in. There is a ring on the back where a soup bowl was set down before the ink was dry. The ring is entered as a separate exhibit. It establishes that the card was used at a table where people were fed, and the Floor has found that fact more predictive than most signatures.

The instruction sheet. One sheet, folded once. The front prints the instructions reproduced below. The back prints a worked example: a transcription of a real rev. 1 card, retyped by the Society with permission. The card it transcribes is not in this clip. It is held elsewhere, and the apparatus below says where.

What follows is the base recension: the card and the sheet, as a volunteer would have met them, once, quickly, with a pen already uncapped. It was written by people who were not writing anything down for us. We have not corrected it. We have annotated it in this hand, in drawers. Where the card tells a volunteer to write down what a person said and not what the volunteer understood, the Floor has tried to hold itself to the same rule. Whether it has managed is for the drawers to show, and the Floor has not read them back.

A note for the newly assigned: the card went through four revisions. The Floor holds rev. 1 (in another custody) and rev. 4. Revisions 2 and 3 were, according to the Society’s minutes, “used up.”


KSAS Form 1 — Case Intake Card

One box for what happened. One box for what they wrote down. Mind the gap.

KEEFER STREET ACCOMPANIMENT SOCIETY · FORM 1 · CASE INTAKE CARD · rev. 4, May 2026

We meet on the unceded territories of the xʷməθkʷəy̓əm (Musqueam), Sḵwx̱wú7mesh (Squamish), and səl̓ilwətaɬ (Tsleil-Waututh) Nations.

Thursdays, 5 to 8, the hall under the church at Keefer and Princess. Side door. Knock twice. The buzzer is being fixed.

Printed at cost by FuReFu. Soup by the Votary Cook.

⟢ Zetetic hand — masthead

No finding. The acknowledgement is the one line the Society carried unchanged through all four revisions, and the only line on the card that points to a record older than any office named on it. The Floor does not annotate that record. It is not the Floor’s.

The buzzer is annotated separately.1 So is the printer’s credit.2

I.0 — Before you pick up the pen

You are not a lawyer. You are not a caseworker. You are not, whatever the person across the table hopes, the office that should have helped them. You are a person with a pen, a card, and a bowl of soup going cold. Your whole job is to write down what they tell you, so that later, when someone official says it never happened, there is a piece of paper that says it did.

That is less than it sounds like. It is also more.

Three rules:

  1. Write what they said, not what you understood. If they say “the lady on the phone hung up on me,” do not write “call disconnected.” The office will write “call disconnected.” That is the office’s job. Yours is the lady.
  2. Two sets of initials on every card. One of you listens and one of you writes. Swap when the soup runs out. If there’s only one of you, the card waits until there are two. The card can wait. The card is used to it.
  3. Never fill in Side B from memory. Side B is for paper. If there’s no paper, Side B stays empty, and the empty box is the finding.

II.0 — Side A: What happened

Date. Today’s date, not the date it happened. The date it happened goes under What happened. Offices mix these up constantly. It isn’t our job to help.

What do you want to be called? Not their legal name unless they want it. Some people want to be called “the tenant in 208.” That’s fine. The card has room.

Which office? Name it the way they name it. If they say “the transit people,” write “the transit people.” Underneath, in small letters, write what you think that means. Keep the two apart.

What happened. Their words. Use the back if you run out. Use a second card if you run out of back. Staple, don’t tape. Tape lets go by November.

What were they told happened? This is a different question, so ask it separately. People usually know the answer, and nobody has ever asked them.

Reference number. If the office gave them one, copy it exactly, dashes and all. If the office didn’t give them one, write NONE GIVEN in capitals. Don’t leave it blank. A blank looks like we forgot. NONE GIVEN looks like they did.

⟢ Zetetic hand — II.0, reference number

Recorded. This is the earliest instrument in the file built to register an attempt that no office registered. It works by refusing to leave a blank, which is harder than it sounds: blanks are the natural state of paper, and most forms are designed to return to that state as soon as nobody is looking.

The Floor’s own accession form has a field with a related purpose, SOURCE REFERENCE, which is mandatory. The Floor notes the resemblance and has not established which came first. The accession of this card is described in a footnote, as a matter of routine.3

How was the room? Tick one or more: ☐ loud ☐ warm ☐ tired ☐ flat ☐ humming

We added this line in rev. 3 at the suggestion of our friends from FuReFu, who play here on the last Friday of the month. They noticed, before we did, that some weeks the room is different and nobody writes it down. This line isn’t about the person. It’s about the room. Tick what the room was like while you talked.

Humming is new in rev. 4. It’s the Votary Cook’s word, borrowed from a FuReFu song. Tick it if the room seemed fine and you didn’t believe it. If you don’t know what that means, don’t tick it. You’ll know.

⟢ Zetetic hand — II.0, the room

Indicative only. The Floor ran the room ticks from every surviving rev. 3 and rev. 4 card as a proxy for collective valence. The sample is one basement, the instrument is a volunteer with a pen, and the error bars are wider than the room.4

Humming was ticked eleven times. The Floor must separate two things the one word carries. The Votary Cook’s hum named a condition the city already had and could describe without instruments: the rent notice, the app alert, the shift before sunrise, the grocery bill done as arithmetic, everything priced and nothing secure.5 The field the Floor later measured, from 2034, used that condition as its carrier. The Floor calls the field the Terminal Hum, to keep it apart from the condition. The card ticks the condition. It could not tick the field. Nothing could, yet.

The Floor enters the Votary Cook’s gloss, the room seemed fine and you didn’t believe it, as the earliest plain-speech definition in the file. No later definition has improved on it.

III.0 — Side B: What the office recorded

Fill this side in only from paper: paper they brought, paper they were sent, or paper we got for them. Don’t fill it in from what they remember the office saying. That goes on Side A.

What the office recorded. Copy the office’s words exactly, including the ones that make you angry. Especially those.

Copies taken. What we photocopied, how many pages, and who has the originals. They keep the originals. Always. We keep copies. We’re not an office.

Next step. One line. Something someone will actually do, with a name next to it.

Initials (listener) ________ (writer) ________

Now fold the card along the dotted line so Side A faces Side B. The fold isn’t decoration. If the two sides say the same thing, good: file the card and have more soup. If they don’t, the gap between them is the reason we exist.

⟢ Zetetic hand — III.0, the fold

Confirmed. The fold is the whole method. Where the testimony and the record disagree, the disagreement is the case. Where they agree, there is nothing to audit.6 The Floor calls this Un-Writing and has devoted a chapter to it. The Society called it folding the card.

IV.0 — A worked example

We print one real card on the back of this instruction sheet, with permission, so new volunteers can see what a finished one looks like. This one was filled in before the room line existed. So the box isn’t blank. It didn’t exist yet. Those are different things, and the difference matters.

Date: 1 March 2024
Call me: Rosa
Office: “the ride booking”
(small: AccessRide — the regional door-to-door service. Vendor? Ask.)
What happened: “I phoned on the 13th to complain because my rides got cancelled when the website was down and I missed my appointment at VGH. The man was nice. He said he can’t take it without a booking number. There’s no booking number because the booking got cancelled. He said he’d write it down somewhere. I don’t know where somewhere is.”
What she was told happened: “That there was nothing to complain about yet.”
Reference number: NONE GIVEN
How was the room: (not on this revision)


What the office recorded: (no paper)
Copies taken: Phone bill, one page, showing a call on 13 Feb at 11:42, 19 minutes. Rosa keeps the original.
Next step: Bernadette helps file a written complaint Monday.
Initials: B.O. / D.W.

Bernadette filed it on the Monday. That time they gave her a number. It isn’t on this card, because this card was filled in on the Friday. It’s on the next one.

⟢ Zetetic hand — IV.0, what the card can carry

The Floor separates what this card proves from what it only permits.

Proved: that on 1 March 2024 a woman who asked to be called Rosa sat at a table in a church hall in Strathcona and said these things in front of two witnesses, one of whom was eating. Proved, by the bill: a call on 13 February, nineteen minutes long.

Not proved: what was said during those nineteen minutes. The call recording was retained for ninety days. The Floor requested it in its fourth year.

Don’t read the man was nice as an aside. It is the only character reference in the file for whoever took the call.7

For scale: Inquiry 7, which reviewed complaint intake at the regional door-to-door service for 2024 to 2027, reported that it had received no qualifying evidence of complaint attempts going unrecorded at intake. The Floor cites this only to show how unusual Rosa’s case was.

⟢ Zetetic hand — the next card

Location: Society file on CX-24-0417, item 1b (see that file, II.0, Contents).

Status: withheld from this transcription, not missing. A missing card is one the Floor cannot find. A withheld card is one the Floor can find and will not move. Item 1b belongs to the Society file’s custody, and the Floor does not move items between custodies to make a reading easier.

A reader who wants the number has to go there. A reader who goes there will find it, and will then have to come back here, to IV.0, where the field still reads NONE GIVEN. The field has not been amended. The Floor was offered the authority to amend it and declined.


ΔSTATE: ANNOTATED. Form 1 is entered as the earliest two-box intake instrument in the file. NONE GIVEN is entered as a finding type. Humming is entered as the plain- speech name of the Hum, the condition, as distinct from the Terminal Hum, the field. No correction has been made to the base recension.

Open: IV.0, Reference number, NONE GIVEN. Unamended.

[STAMP]
NOT A RECORD OF WHAT HAPPENED // A RECORD OF WHAT WAS SAID
KEEP THE SOUP AWAY FROM THE INK


Every copy from that duplicator carries a hairline through the lower bowl of the numeral 8, where the stencil drum was cracked. The hairline is on rev. 4 of this card. It is on the Society’s October 2026 newsletter. It is also on the earliest surviving printing of the Floor’s own accession form, running through the 8 in Form A-8. The Floor’s first forms were run on surplus equipment bought at auction, as a great many things were. Duplicators of that model crack in the same place after enough years, and a technician has confirmed this for the Floor, citing a service manual the Floor has not been able to locate. The Floor draws no conclusion. It notes that it has not been able to establish where its own form came from, and that it has been asked the question before.

The Floor’s proxy calculation, attached as Schedule R, uses the ticks as ordinal data only. An earlier draft of Schedule R treated them as interval data and found a correlation of 0.83 between humming ticks and the regional valence decline recorded a decade later. The figure was striking. It was cited in the Floor’s application to renew its Social Weather desk, and the desk was renewed. The Floor then noticed that eleven ticks cannot carry two decimal places, withdrew the draft, and destroyed it. It lawfully retains the certificate of destruction. The renewal has not been revisited, because a granted renewal is reviewed on its own schedule.

The Floor wishes to be clear that it did not ask for the renewal to stand. It wishes to be equally clear that it did not ask for it to be reviewed. The Floor’s position is that the desk does useful work. It is aware that it is paid to hold that position, and aware that being paid to hold a position doesn’t make the position wrong. It is also aware that this is exactly what a desk would say.

Marchetti came to soup night fifteen months after this card was written. Before anyone had mentioned the case, she asked whether a woman named Rosa still came on Thursdays.


  1. The buzzer at the side door is reported as “being fixed” on rev. 1 (2023), on rev. 4 (2026), and on every Society notice the Floor has located up to the last one it holds, dated 2028. The Floor first logged this as a maintenance failure. On review it has been reclassified as a door policy. A door that has to be knocked on twice selects for visitors who expected to knock, and against anyone sent by an office, since offices phone ahead and nobody here answers the phone. The Floor makes no finding on whether this was intended. It notes that nobody fixed the buzzer in five years, and nobody complained. ↩

  2. FuReFu printed revisions 3 and 4 at cost, on a stencil duplicator kept at their practice space, because, in the words of the minutes, “they don’t trust the laser.” The Compendium dates the establishment of the Futilitarian Relief Fund to 2028, and a second volume dates its emergence as a recognized cell to mid-century. The Society’s papers show the band playing the hall from 2024. The Floor rules, provisionally, that a collective is established when it is constituted, and that before then it is only playing. The Votary Cook is a persona, not a person. The soup was real regardless. ↩

  3. The card reached the Floor as part of a deposit from a private custodian. The accession clerk copied each field the Floor’s Form A-8 requires from the card, including SOURCE REFERENCE, which the clerk took from the card’s reference number: NONE GIVEN. Form A-8 does not accept an empty identifier. It also does not accept NONE GIVEN, which it reads as an attempt to fill a mandatory field without supplying one. The card was therefore held as unaccessioned correspondence, pending an identifier. Unaccessioned correspondence is kept complete and can be read by anyone, as this reading shows. It is not evidence, because by definition evidence is what has been accessioned. The identifier the card needs is the one the office did not issue. The Floor has written to the office. The office replied that it cannot issue a reference for an attempt it did not record, and it enclosed a reference number for the Floor’s letter. ↩

  4. The room line asks what the Floor’s later instruments ask, in fewer words and with worse calibration. Itch-era community groups, keeping analogue logs of social weather (who stopped singing, which streets felt flattened, whether people still borrowed salt from each other), were asking the room’s question eight years after this card asked it. The Floor claims a resemblance, not a line of descent. It notes that the resemblance runs through the same kind of place: a borrowed room, a kitchen, a table where somebody was feeding somebody else. ↩

  5. The condition was described in print in the same years, in an anonymous pamphlet of ten refusals, Against the Hum, sold for a dollar at FuReFu’s merchandise table. It opens: “I first felt the Hum not as an idea, but as a bodily fact.” The Floor’s copy is a stencil print with the hairline through the 8 on the last page. ↩

  6. Of the cards on which the two sides agreed, the Floor has audited none, there being nothing to audit. A representative example, from rev. 3: Side A, What happened: “call disconnected.” Side B, What the office recorded: “call disconnected.” The Floor filed it with the others. ↩

  7. The Floor holds a signed statement from T. Marchetti, then a contact-centre agent for the Authority’s Passenger Service Line, who says she took this call. Rosa’s card says a man did. The Floor has not resolved the difference. The recording that would settle it is the one retained for ninety days. Rosa may have misheard a voice through a poor connection. Marchetti may be remembering another call from the same week, of which, by her account, there were many. The Floor enters the statement as testimony and the card as testimony, and does not rank them. ↩